Bills 20, Chiefs 17

With unlimited pre-snap motion which allows all receivers and backfield personnel to charge the line of scrimmage with a running start, on almost any play in a typical CFL game, it looks to me like at least one offensive player is offside, crossing the line before the ball is snapped. I have never seen it called. In American football which limits pre-snap motion to one player, the other ten players must be lined up and set for one second before the snap. Receivers must not line up ahead of where the ball lies. It’s pretty simple. I don’t think I’ve ever seen offensive offside called in an NFL game – until yesterday. As Gene Staratore, former NFL referee and CBS in-house officiating commentator posted on his Twitter account last night, it is almost never called because offensive players almost never line up ahead of where the ball is spotted. But when they do, shouldn’t it be called?

I watched Patrick Mahomes post-game press conference last night. When the game ended, he was visibly upset, slamming his helmet and screaming at someone on the Chiefs sideline. He explained that he was upset at the call which negated a “hall of fame play by a hall of fame player”. And it also happened to be what could have been the game-winning touchdown. He explained that playing organized football going back as far as he could remember, this isn’t called before multiple warnings are issued by officials. As kids playing football, receivers would take their place at the line of scrimmage and look at the line judge who would then indicate that they were positioned correctly or motion them to move back as needed. Last night, no such warnings were issued (probably because there were no infractions) but as referee Carl Jeffers said afterward, “if it’s egregious enough, it would be beyond a warning”. Chiefs coach Andy Reid corroborated his quarterback’s analysis after the game saying that he would typically be given a warning before a call is made and that “it’s a bit embarrassing for the National Football League for that to take place”. There is no question that Chiefs receiver Kadarius Toney was lined up forward of the ball on the fateful play. The camera angles showed very clearly that he was lined well forward of the ball. Mahomes said that when he saw the flag fly before he made his throw to Kelce, he assumed that it was for defensive offside (sometimes called a “neutral zone infraction”).    

It seems clear to me that the real issue was that the penalty call – which was correct by any standard – negated a brilliant play by Travis Kelce which could have and probably would have been the game-winning touchdown. Had the call been made on a three yard run or a short pass to Kelce, it would not be the subject of such scrutiny this morning. Successful offensive plays are regularly called back in football games – for holding penalties, for players illegally downfield, for offensive pass interference, etc. It’s part of the game and always will be. The play by Kelce where he made the catch 25 yards downfield then turned and threw a perfect lateral to (ironically) Kadarius Toney who streaked down the left sideline and into the endzone was a highlight reel play for sure and had it stood as the game-winning play, would surely have been in the season’s top ten plays. But it doesn’t appear in the boxscore this morning and basically never happened.

Were I a Chiefs fan this morning looking back at the plays which changed the trajectory of the game, I would be focused on the Josh Allen “completion” to Latavius Murray which kept the Bills drive alive and allowed them to kick the what became the game-winning field goal. As he fell out of bounds, Allen floated a pass to Murray who got his hands on it and as Gene Steratore explained, appeared to complete the requisite three steps needed to make it a completion before fumbling. The ball was then pushed out of bounds on the ensuing scramble and the Bills maintained possession. When CBS went to commercial for the replay review, I was convinced that the ruling would be overturned based on the angles shown. I am equally convinced this morning that had the pass been ruled incomplete on the field, that would have been upheld.

The Bills find themselves still in the AFC playoff contention, although just barely because at 7-6, they are tied with five other teams all pursuing two wildcard playoff spots. Since all but one of the Bills losses this year have been to AFC teams, the Bills would lose most tie-breaker scenarios so a prolonged winning streak will be required and still might not be enough.

Up next: The Dallas Cowboys make their once-every-eight-years trip to Orchard Park next Sunday for another 4.25pm start. The Bills are early two point favourites.