Tuesday, 15 October 2013

Bengals 27, Bills 24 OT

I try to watch Mark Shields and David Brooks every Friday on the PBS Newshour. They provide their analysis of the week's news and events, mostly focusing on US politics. Shields is a syndicated columnist - and more of a liberal - while Brooks is a columnist with the New York Times -and more of a conservative. Neither is partisan for or against either of the two major US political parties and, while they often disagree, they do so in a more respectful and considerate way than just about any other political panel I can think of.

This past Friday, they discussed the current US government shutdown and the looming possibility that the government could default on its debt obligations. Both agreed that the position taken by House Tea Party Republicans is quickly driving down the popularity of the Republican Party. I guess I knew that but the extent of the damage, according to Shields and Brooks, was a bit of a surprise to me. Shields suggested that the Republican Party now has the support of about 28% of the American population. This level of support would be good in four party system but, in a two party system, it is disastrous. Not that I really mind seeing the GOP self-destruct, but when the world's financial system is potentially put at risk, something needs to be done.

The problem is that certain Tea Party Republicans ran on the basis that they would fight for their issues (reversing the Affordable Care Act, cuts to entitlements etc) and that in the course of the fight, they would not compromise. The American legislative system is based on compromise and without it, over the course of the country's history, very few legislative initiatives would have ever been come to pass. I understand that the Tea Party does not support Obamcare and that they want cuts to social security to balance the budget - I really do understand that (although I don't agree) - but not being willing to compromise is recipe for a failure of the system. Imagine if a group of Democrats refused to raise the debt ceiling unless significant gun control or carbon emission legislation were passed.

The GOP is being punished (rightly) in public opinion polls. I am not naive enough to think that only 28% of the American public supports the Tea Party's position on the issues. I am certain that's not the case. But what does seem likely is that three quarters of Americans oppose the idea of a refusal to compromise. And so they should. There are now two days left to get some kind of a deal before the US defaults on its debt obligations and sends the world economy off the edge. House Speaker John Boehner has publicly suggested that the President seems like he will settle for nothing less than a total surrender by House Democrats whereby they would gain virtually nothing in whatever deal emerges. At least he's right about that.      

No comments:

Post a Comment